One of the fundamental practices of Freemasonry is that we do not discuss religion or politics in lodge. That prohibition is carried out into the world to an extent. Most Regular Masonic jurisdictions enjoin a practice of restricting the use of masonic symbols. For instance, in California we are enjoined not to use the Square and Compass device on our business cards, in our business logo, on our business signage... and in our politics. So when we find a brother using the square and compass to promote his political views, it is all the more surprising.
Recently, a brother expressed support for a third party candidate for political office. On the surface, there is no problem with a brother, or any citizen, choosing to support someone for office. The problem arises when a mason, using a forum marked as masonic, regardless of personal disclaimers, advocates as a mason, his support for a political candidate.
Some brothers have noted that what he has done is little different from placing a political sticker on a car that also has masonic badges on it, though the argument is little disingenuous. The only reason for posting a political opinion on a blog ostensibly aimed at masons is to reach out TO masons, to push your opinion as a mason onto masons.
Keeping in mind my own credo regarding freemasonry: Its not about me changing them, its about me changing me, I am not so much worried about a brother wrapping himself in politics, but that in doing so as a mason, he may be losing sight of that valuable instrument by which we are taught to circumscribe our passions and keep them within due bounds toward all mankind, particularly our brethren in freemasonry.
Because politics are divisive by their very nature, we, as Freemasons, should not be playing at them and aiming them at our brethren. Posting political opinion to masons is akin to using the lodge mailing list to send out political flyers on lodge letterhead. This is never a good thing, and is only cause for distention from brothers who do not agree with the candidate/position being advocated in their name.
We should always remember that freemasonry is about improving ourselves, not selling soaps, powders, or politics, and anything that detracts from that lofty goal should be avoided. After all, there is a time and a place for religious observation and a time and a place for politics. Lodge is not a place for them, and mailing to, or reaching out to brothers on a forum, blog or web space set aside or dedicated to freemasonry is not the place for such a divisive topic as political advocacy.
May the blessings of heaven rest upon us and all regular masons. May brotherly love prevail, and every moral and social virtue, cement us.
Bro. Theron I am confused by this one I have to say.
ReplyDeleteI don’t like WS support of clandestine Masonry, but I find it funny that you separate yourself by claiming that he supports “extremely” clandestine Masonry, positioning yourself as somehow better by supporting clandestine Masonry that is somehow less extreme.
You publicly declare yourself on your forum as a member of California’s Masonic Formation, participate in a forum with Masonic symbols, and then fly to the aid of a clandestine Mason and one time member of the UGLoA. How would your Grand Secretary feel about that? Or the committee chair, Brother Martin I think. I would be willing to bet they wouldn’t like the idea. Does that mean it is un-Masonic. I don’t think so, just distasteful.
I just think you ought to evaluate your own behavior before threatening such things, because your public stance on Vulcan and Euclid Lodge side by side with your proclamation that you are a part of a Grand Lodge committee on Masonic Formation could clearly be seen as a conflict of interest.
How many of those formation meetings have you actually made since you like to declare it anyway?
Tell you what, JP's Daddy. Why don't you call them and ask them. Would you like me to provide you with their phone numbers or email addresses so you can ask?
ReplyDeleteFeel free to email me and I will put you in contact with those worthies so you can ask them yourself. You see, unlike some, I have no fear that my actions are in any way inconsistent with masonic teachings.
I am SURE that they would entirely me aiding and assisting a man in need of assistance.
And, what has been my public stance on Vulcan and Euclid lodge? Please direct me to any public statement I have made regarding either lodge, please, as support for your contention.
Please review what I have actually stated on this blog at Acknowledgment vs recognition:
http://beaconofmasoniclight.blogspot.com/2007/11/acknowledgement-vs-recognition.html
before going off half cocked with wild accusations.
Meantime, thank you for posting and proving my point for me.
No music to your ears like the sound of your own voice, is there.
ReplyDeleteNice anonymous... real nice. You don't sign your post, so you apparently don't have the courage of your convictions.
ReplyDeleteI sign my name, proudly, to what I write... when someone really thinks something, he actually puts his name to it... like John Hancock and Benjamin Franklin did.
Imagine if the masonic founders of this country had cowered behind "anonymous". Do you think the king of England would have been impressed?
I am no king, but i am not impressed either. At least JPs daddy, disagreeing with me, had the courage of HIS convictions to sign his post. Him I admire and respect, even if I disagree with him.
Actually,
ReplyDeleteMany of our founding fathers did do things anonymously, ie the Sons of Liberty, but that is another story for another time.
I agree with putting my name to all that I post.
Br. Arthur Peterson AKA JewBelow
As Widow's Son does not publish his name on Burning Taper - for whatever reasons - I think that for you to make it public was uncalled for.
ReplyDeletePlease note that I'm not disagreeing with your comments about WS. He and I have had some of our own disagreements, and it certainly does seem that he has allowed his perceptions of Georgia Masonry to portray the entire fraternity in a less than flattering light at times. I'm writing this because I believe that a person's desire for anonymity on the internet should be respected.
You've written some excellent articles and your posts elsewhere have always been insightful and well-thought out - even when I've disagreed with them. I'm not sure what prompted this breach of netiquette, but it seems to run counter to what I've seen of your thoughtful manner in the past. Yes, I did read the "hissy fit" article, and frankly, the entire argument - indeed, the entire Masonic blogging community of late - is beginning to look a lot like a junior high school playground. Maybe everybody is stressed because of all the last minute holiday shopping or the rush to finish their work by year end. Whatever the reason, it would be nice to see everybody take a breath and get some perspective, if not on the issues, then at least to get a handle on how they are all presenting themselves to each other and to the rest of the world.
The true name of Widow's Son is hardly a secret. It took all of five minutes to find it. I do not hold with anonymous attacks, and I see the Widow's Son's criticisms of ME and not my point to be attacks. Therefore, I posted his name, because, after all, I post in MY name.
ReplyDeleteHowever, Widow's Son has asked me to remove the reference to his real name as a mason, in obvious distress. Therefore, I have removed all references to his name.
My apologies to the Widow's Son.
If it's not really about you changing them, then STFU!
ReplyDeleteI personally find political bumper stickers next to masonic ones pretty tacky as well. Usually, those stickers are of the confrontational kind--sort of like "America, love it or leave it", or "My Way or the Highway", or some other retarded slogan.
ReplyDeleteNot that anybody shouldn't express themselves, but listen, bumperstickers and sloganeering (of which many American masons have no shortage) are the lowest common denominator. Then you have the readers of such dross link confrontational politics with the Craft, which leads them down the slippery slope to believe that ALL Freemasons (never mind that we are an international fraternity) are engaged in right wing politics and creepy plans for civilization.
While some brethren have these predilections, I prefer them to keep it in their pants--especially in public where most people judge now and ask questions later (or never as the case may be until there's a special on the History or Discovery Channels).
Bro. Wepwawet
Bro:. Theron,
ReplyDeleteThe Widow's Son reports that he previously asked you to keep his real name confidential and that you agreed. Is this true?
I will reserve further comment until I hear your side of the story.
Tony
I do not recall that he asked me never to reveal his name. I recall that we were in a heated discussion regarding his blog and the Lodgeroom US. He asked that I take his name off the comments, and in return, he would remove my name from his form where he was quoting me.
ReplyDeleteI agreed. As I recall, there was no request beyond that. His name is hardly secret, and while I find his threats... amusing, considering how he has in shorts in a bind because I asked him if he wanted to call his Junior Warden over his political postings.
He emailed me this morning, asking me about it, and I stated I would remove his name and never reveal it again... this morning. I have not violated my obligation in any way, despite his many and several personal attacks.
This is my "side" of the story. If anyone wants to contact my junior warden, feel free. I know the masonic code, and I know what I have and have not done regarding it.
What is laughable in this whole situation is that WS has called out lots of people by name, attacking them when he disagrees with them, posting their photos (as he did for Brother Dunn) and publicly castigating them. But, he wants to reserve the for himself to do this in private and not have is own name brought up.
ReplyDeleteWhy am I posting anonymously? Because, while WS brooks no one posting his name, he moves into attack mode against anyone who disagrees with him.
SHOULD YOU BE INTERESTED TO JOIN THE HOOD KINDLY WHATSAPP/CALL +1 202 750 0111 OR EMAIL illuminatiempire084@gmail.com NOW
ReplyDeleteThere's one old secret that has worked for quite a good number of people.
I tapped into it some times ago and so far,it has been working for me.
Simple!!!
Whatever you think of often, becomes your reality.
Further put, whichever way you condition your mind,
the universe connives to give it to you.
But as simple as it is, it is the hardest thing to do.
You must have heard stories of unmerited favour right?
That's the Universe conniving to give to you what you have
conditioned your mind to get.
It happens, it always does.
I can't start giving explanations about my life... This isn't about
me, it is about you reading this message
Though a beautiful example is myself.
I became very close to my dream when I realize how much important i needed to channel my energy towards positive vibes. Which brings us to the the reason why you must join illuminati.
Clerics will tell you, there is power in the tongue............. well, they fail to tell you where the real power is: Your MIND.
That is where the thought is first conceived before it is spoken. Brothers and Sisters condition your mind to positivity by joining illuminati hood today and see it
manifest in your life. I know it's hard here because of scams you might have gone through previously but believe me as a member of the hood i promise to help you and get initiated to the hood so you can enjoy your life with wealth, fame and power.
As a new member initiated to the illuminati hood, a cash sum of $2,000,000.00 will be credited to your bank account including a house in any country of your choice and also a brand new car of your dream. Mind you, all this will be given to YOU immediately after your initiation to the illuminati hood.
I know you has a positive mindset to join the hood. Should you be interested, contact whatsapp/Call +1 202 750 0111, you can also email illuminatiempire084@gmail.com
with your loyalty and positive mindset let's get started.Mind you!! ILLUMINATI BROTHERHOOD IS ARENA OF WEALTH , POWER AND FAME.